The Between the Sheets Cocktail: Better Than the Sidecar?

The Between the Sheets is one of the most elegant and misunderstood classics in the cocktail world — a sophisticated twist on the Sidecar that swaps in a touch of rum for extra depth and character. Believed to have originated in the 1920s at Harry’s New York Bar in Paris, the cocktail is often attributed to legendary bartender Harry MacElhone, though its exact origins remain the subject of spirited debate. Regardless of who first mixed it, the Between the Sheets has earned its place as a Prohibition-era classic, blending citrus brightness with the richness of fine spirits. In this video, we’re making the drink with Ron del Barrilito rum, St-Rémy Brandy, and Cointreau for a combination that is smooth, layered, and incredibly well-balanced. Fresh lemon juice brings everything together, creating a cocktail that is equal parts refreshing and spirit-forward. This is the kind of drink that showcases how a few simple ingredients can create something truly timeless. Whether you’re exploring pre-Prohibition cocktails, building your home bar repertoire, or just looking for your next favorite classic, the Between the Sheets is a drink that deserves a second look.