Praying w/ Heretics, Justification & JesusAndWhatNot
Wagner from Scholastic Answers joins the stream for a deep-dive into several Catholic theological topics: the morality of praying with heretics (communicatio in sacris), what religious submission (obsequium religiosum) Catholics actually owe to various Church documents, and a thorough Thomistic breakdown of justification and the difference between the Old and New Law. Along the way they defend the unique authority of St. Thomas Aquinas, explain first vs. second justification, and address common Protestant objections rooted in Galatians and Romans. The second half opens up to audience super-chats, covering everything from young-earth creationism and salvation outside the Church to martyrdom, papal heresy, and a long stretch of unfiltered off-the-cuff banter. Check out: @Jesus.andwhatnot My links: Patreon: / militantthomist Substack: https://substack.com/@scholasticanswers 🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 https://streamyard.com/pal/d/61587531... Conents: 00:00 Introduction 00:57 The Authority of St. Thomas Aquinas 05:10 Controversy Over Predestination & Theological Irreverence 14:27 The Morality of Praying with Heretics (Communicatio in Sacris) 22:00 Practical Scenarios & The Principle of "Passive Presence" 27:00 Understanding "Obsequium Religiosum" (Religious Submission) 32:35 Catholic Justification: Initial Justification Explained 38:35 Catholic Justification: The Old Law vs. The New Covenant 46:47 Catholic Justification: Meriting & The Analogy of the Coin 52:57 The Online Apologetics Sphere & "Slop" Content 56:51 The "NeedGod.net" Controversy & Engagement Bait 01:02:09 Super Chats Begin: Young Earth Creationism & Salvation 01:08:20 Responding to Viewer Questions (Hell, Martyrs, & Church History) 01:14:53 The Filioque, Liberal Democracy, & Historical Reliability of the Gospels 01:22:20 Addressing Viewer's Questions on Dating and Intimacy 01:30:14 More Viewer Questions: Micro Penis Discourse 01:36:12 Theological Deep-Dives & Practical Advice for Seminarians 01:48:19 Controversial Takes on King Leopold II & a Hypothetical Crusade 02:00:00 Closing Remarks & Shilling the Substack #Protestantism #Catholicism #Christianity

Responding to Anti-Catholic Claims | AMA Catholicism w/@shamelesspopery

Do I Regret Joining The Daily Wire? | Cameron Fradd | Last Call Ep. 22

Who Is the AOCC? And Are They Really Orthodox?

The trial just exposed everything..

How Do You Make a Good confession? Overcoming Sin w/Tim Staples

A Former Evangelical Seminary Professor Explains Why the Bible Made Him Catholic

Miracles Prove Catholicism: The Ethan Muse Interview

Did John copy a lost gospel? 1 letter could be proof

Catholicism VINDICATED on Communion in One Kind

Vatican II: Modernism Vs. Tradition at the Council | Dr. Peter Kwasniewski

Bad Popes are Why I'm Not Catholic...

Why Every Orthodox Man Needs a Parish Family (Fr. Stephen De Young)

Is the Novus Ordo Less Catholic Than the TLM? | Dr. Peter Kwasniewski

Fr. Gregory Pine on the SSPX

Do Not Be Afraid - SSPX Sermons

DEBATE REVIEW: Redeemed Zoomer vs Doug Wilson on SCHISM

Eucharistic Miracles: Heaven's Evidence on Earth | Shaun McAfee

Santo Rosário | Sexta-feira | 04:00 | 03/07/2026 | Live Ao vivo

SSPX: Both Sides of the Controversy | Fr. Gerald Murray, J.C.D. & Fr. Jonathan Loop, FSSPX

