Советские лётчики – неумелые, но смелые? Почему я не верю Тимину. 10:1 в пользу Люфтваффе Ч.2

What is it that writer Mikhail Timin can't understand that any pilot or aircraft engineer knows? A professional pilot criticizes renowned aviation expert Timin for his ignorance of aviation and hasty conclusions. Timin believes that Soviet fighter pilots during World War II paid for every one German aircraft shot down with the loss of 10 of their own! In the first part of the video, we discussed how and where Mikhail Timin went wrong when he recalculated Luftwaffe losses and reduced them by a factor of 5! But apparently, 10 to 1 wasn't working, so Mikhail decided to recalculate total Soviet aircraft losses... What mistake, unworthy of an expert (an error on par with a complete aviation amateur), Timin made in doing so. And how did this happen to a recognized expert... In three consecutive videos, writer Mikhail Timin shared his historical "discovery" with his viewers. According to him, Soviet fighter pilots during World War II paid for every one German aircraft shot down with the loss of 10 of their own! In other words, the Luftwaffe had a 10:1 advantage in aerial combat between German aces and Soviet pilots on the Soviet-German front! He is confident in his conclusion and believes his statement is difficult to refute! However, a professional pilot with experience in the Soviet Air Force noticed four errors in Mikhail's thought process and calculations... In this video, you have the opportunity to follow Mikhail Timin's calculations with pilot Vladimir Potapov and consider whether and how much he is mistaken in his calculations. In the first part, we discussed how and why Mikhail Timin miscalculated the Luftwaffe's losses and reduced them by a factor of five! But apparently 10 to 1 wasn't working, and Mikhail decided to recalculate the total Soviet aircraft losses... What mistake, unworthy of an expert, did Timin make (an error worthy of an amateur in aviation). And how did this happen to a recognized expert? The Great Patriotic War. World War II. Eastern Front. Yakovlev fighters. Yak-1, Yak-3, Yak-9. Yak-52 sports plane. DOSAAF USSR. La-7, La-5. I-16. Mikhail Timin on the problems of accounting for aircraft losses    • Михаил Тимин о проблемах учета потерь само...   Timing of M. Timin's video: 20:00 Counting Soviet losses 22:40 The Germans didn't hide their losses 33:00 Losses 10:1 "10 times" with time reference:    • Михаил Тимин отвечает на вопросы зрителей ...      • Михаил Тимин о проблемах учета потерь само...   35:00 Losses on the Eastern Front 42:08 How can't they be counted? 01:38:00 They should be more proud The second video where Mikhail repeats roughly the same thing about losses and other things... Mikhail Timin answers questions from viewers of "Archive" Revolution"    • Михаил Тимин отвечает на вопросы зрителей ...   Mikhail assesses the losses and explains why we should be even more proud    • Михаил Тимин отвечает на вопросы зрителей ...   Video timing by M. Timin: 1:52:00 ...even more proud... 2:50:29 How German losses should not be counted Information and tables used in the video: Personnel training, table 1: http://stsokol.ru/vvs_tsifra/gl_5/5.1... Advanced training courses during the war http://stsokol.ru/vvs_tsifra/gl_5/5.1... Flight hours during training of one pilot on a combat aircraft and the number of flights performed by type of training in the reserve air regiments of the Red Army Air Forces 1941-1945 http://stsokol.ru/vvs_tsifra/gl_5/5.2... Basic summary data on Soviet and Nazi German aviation http://stsokol.ru/vvs_tsifra/gl_1/ind... Combat losses of Soviet and German aviation in aircraft for 1941-1945 (According to information from the Operations Directorate of the General Staff of the Air Force, the Long-Range Aviation Headquarters, the Air Defense Headquarters, and the Naval Aviation Headquarters http://stsokol.ru/vvs_tsifra/gl_1/1.1... G.F. Krivosheev (edited). Russia and the USSR in the Wars of the 20th Century: Armed Forces Losses Search the table of contents for: Chapter V. THE GREAT PATRIOTIC WAR (conclusion). Armament and Combat Equipment. Production and Losses http://lib.ru/MEMUARY/1939-1945/KRIWO... Film by Vladimir Potapov Filming Clouds by Vladimir Potapov Music from the YouTube music library.    / @vladimirskyartist   Hello, my name is Vladimir Potapov! I'm a professional pilot with a higher education in flight since 1992. I flew in the army and civilian life, as an instructor in DOSAAF, and worked as a teacher at the Aviation Training Center. Today, I'm a private pilot and enjoy flying my own aircraft (a multi-engine seaplane). On the "Sky Artist" channel, which means "Sky Artist" (and that's certainly not me! ;)), you'll find reviews of aircraft and trips to interesting places. You'll be able to immerse yourself in the history of Russian aviation! I'm very interested in all of this, and I sincerely share it with you!