Guardian Readers vs. Critics: Who Made The Better List?
The Guardian asked readers to vote for the 100 greatest novels of all time. The public has spoken. I still have notes. A couple of weeks ago I worked through the critics' and writers' version of this list — and I had thoughts. Now the readers have had their say, and while I have a lot of respect for democracy, I also have a lot of opinions about what ended up in here. Some of these books absolutely deserve their place. Some of them I cannot let go without comment. And one or two omissions are, frankly, baffling. This is my honest reaction to the Guardian's reader-voted 100 greatest novels. If you haven't watched Part 1: the critics' version, that's on the channel and worth a look before this one. As always, I'd love to know what you think. Did the readers get it right? Were there books on here that surprised you, or glaring omissions you can't forgive? Let me know down in the comments.🔗 Part 1 — The Critics' List: • The Good, The Bad, And The Omissions: The ... 📚 The Book Thing on Discworld: • Discworld in Order: Reviewing Every Terry ... Don't forget to check out @AaronReadABook #GuardianBooks #BestNovels #BookTube #ClassicLiterature #bookreview

10 HARDEST Books I've Read: Are they Worth it?

The Good, The Bad, And The Omissions: The Guardian's 100 Best Novels

My Top 10 Books of 2026 (halfway through the year)

Old Guy Spent 3 Months On BookTok

Book reviews are gaslighting us

Ranking Every Postwar American Novel

Author incomes are dropping and apparently it's our fault

Why I Stopped Collecting Books

Americans Realize Europe Doesn't Follow Their Rules

Why P.G. Wodehouse is More Than Just a Joke

Do You Judge Someone By Their Bookshelf?

January Reading Wrap-Up 📚 From Agatha Christie to Dune (Plus a Surprise 5⭐ Read!)

The Guardian’s 100 Best Novels of All Time Reaction

I missed the most philosophical novel ever written

The Reading Crisis: Are Bookish People Part of the Problem?

The Show Is Better Than the Book (And I Can Prove It) | English PhD Scene Analysis

Does reading make you a better person? | Dominic Sandbrook | The New Society

I Edited 100 Manuscripts. Here Are the 7 Mistakes EVERY Author Makes

3 Five Star Reads in One Month! | March Reading Wrap Up

