Hot Rod vs. Stock: Which Porsche 356 Is Worth More? | Assess and Caress on Jay Leno's Garage

In this episode of Assess and Caress, Jay Leno and appraiser Donald Osborne tackle a question central to the collector car world: Hot Rod or Stock? They compare two Porsches that look similar but have vastly different market stories. Both cars were brought to the garage courtesy of the Our Dream Museum in Newport, Rhode Island. The contenders are a 1959 Porsche 356 1600 Normal and a 1956 Porsche 356 modified by Rod Emory into an "Outlaw". The Stock Car: The 1959 356 Normal is a cherished, two-owner car that has been in the same family for over 30 years and represents a period correct time capsule. Donald is quick to point out the car's amazing build quality and iconic pre-war aerodynamic look. Jay, however, admits that as a young man, he couldn't understand why anyone would buy a 60-horsepower Porsche when a Corvette offered 350 horsepower for less money. The Outlaw: The Rod Emory "Outlaw" is a completely modified, or "reimagined," version of the 356. Emory Motorsports are restorers first, and they use their respect for the original design to create cars that are safer, faster, and more efficient. This particular Outlaw features 260 horsepower—more than four times the power of the stock car—from a custom 2.6-liter four-cylinder engine. Jay and Donald debate which car is the more valuable asset and surprisingly find that the market now rewards both the rare, immaculate originality of the stock car and the thoughtful, modern drivability of the Outlaw almost equally. Shop car care and detailing supplies from Jay Leno’s Garage: https://www.lenosgarage.com/shine » Subscribe: http://bit.ly/JLGSubscribe THE BEST OF JAY LENO'S GARAGE » Exclusive First Looks: http://bit.ly/JLGExclusives » Ultra Rare Supercars: http://bit.ly/JLGSupercars » Jay's Book Club: http://bit.ly/JLGBookClub JAY LENO'S GARAGE ON SOCIAL Facebook:   / jaylenosgarage   Twitter:   / lenosgarage   Instagram:   / jaylenosgarage   TikTok:   / jaylenosgarageofficial   ABOUT JAY LENO'S GARAGE A new video every Monday! Visit Jay Leno's Garage, the Emmy-winning series where Jay Leno gives car reviews, motorcycle reviews, compares cars, and shares his passion and expertise on anything that rolls, explodes, and makes noise. Classic cars, restomods, super cars like the McLaren P1, sports cars like Porsche 918 Spyder and Camaro Z28, cafe racers, vintage cars, and much, much more. #JayLenosGarage #Porsche #Porsche356 #EmoryOutlaw #HotRod #ClassicCars #Restomod #CarCollecting #AssessAndCaress

Jay Leno & John Willhoit Drive the Ultimate Porsche Speedster! | Jay Leno's Garage
▶︎

Jay Leno & John Willhoit Drive the Ultimate Porsche Speedster! | Jay Leno's Garage

The 'Mangy Dog' That Beat Ferrari: American Racing Classics | Assess and Caress on Jay Leno's Garage
▶︎

The 'Mangy Dog' That Beat Ferrari: American Racing Classics | Assess and Caress on Jay Leno's Garage

1963 Porsche 356 drive video
▶︎

1963 Porsche 356 drive video

Millyard RC374 - FULL THROTTLE
▶︎

Millyard RC374 - FULL THROTTLE

We Test 7 Tour De France Bikes From 7 Decades
▶︎

We Test 7 Tour De France Bikes From 7 Decades

This 962 DEREK BELL Signature Edition is a 1 of 1!! |CarsByKendall
▶︎

This 962 DEREK BELL Signature Edition is a 1 of 1!! |CarsByKendall

Jaguar Barn Find & Laser Welding: Jay Leno's Garage Restoration Blog: November 2025
▶︎

Jaguar Barn Find & Laser Welding: Jay Leno's Garage Restoration Blog: November 2025

INSIDE THE MARKET - 356 FACTS & FIGURES
▶︎

INSIDE THE MARKET - 356 FACTS & FIGURES

Jay Leno & Donald Osborne in Audrain Mansions & Motorcars: Fairborne, Season 7 Episode 2
▶︎

Jay Leno & Donald Osborne in Audrain Mansions & Motorcars: Fairborne, Season 7 Episode 2

Nethercutt's 1930 Ruxton – The Forgotten Front-Wheel Drive Pioneer | Jay Leno’s Garage
▶︎

Nethercutt's 1930 Ruxton – The Forgotten Front-Wheel Drive Pioneer | Jay Leno’s Garage

FIRST LOOK: Singer’s Sweet Spot? Red Bull Chassis, Pop-Up Lights, Cosworth 4.0!
▶︎

FIRST LOOK: Singer’s Sweet Spot? Red Bull Chassis, Pop-Up Lights, Cosworth 4.0!

GM Killed These 6 Brands — And Owners Never Forgave Them
▶︎

GM Killed These 6 Brands — And Owners Never Forgave Them

Which of These Cars Lost the MOST Value? | Jay Leno's Garage: Assess & Caress with Donald Osborne
▶︎

Which of These Cars Lost the MOST Value? | Jay Leno's Garage: Assess & Caress with Donald Osborne

Conventional Wisdom Is Wrong | Assess and Caress with Donald Osborne and Jay Leno
▶︎

Conventional Wisdom Is Wrong | Assess and Caress with Donald Osborne and Jay Leno

A GENUINE WORKS AUSTIN HEALEY 3000 | Tyrrell's Classic Workshop
▶︎

A GENUINE WORKS AUSTIN HEALEY 3000 | Tyrrell's Classic Workshop

Ford GT40 vs Ferrari P3 | 1966 Le Mans 24 uur Strijd | The Grand Tour
▶︎

Ford GT40 vs Ferrari P3 | 1966 Le Mans 24 uur Strijd | The Grand Tour

All of Jay Leno's Barn Finds: How He Found Them & Untold Stories | Barn Find Hunter
▶︎

All of Jay Leno's Barn Finds: How He Found Them & Untold Stories | Barn Find Hunter

Porsche in America: The Type 540 Roadster | Full Documentary
▶︎

Porsche in America: The Type 540 Roadster | Full Documentary

What Ferrari Was Like Before It Was Famous
▶︎

What Ferrari Was Like Before It Was Famous

Things I Learned From Restoring My Porsche 356 | Episode 191
▶︎

Things I Learned From Restoring My Porsche 356 | Episode 191