The Problem with Making Wuthering Heights Beautiful

Emerald Fennell’s Wuthering Heights is a neon-soaked fever dream, but is it still Emily Brontë? In this video, The Take dives into why this 2026 adaptation feels more like a Saltburn sequel than a Gothic masterpiece and why it's so dangerous for future generations who watch this film as representative of Bronte's classic masterpiece. We explore how Fennell’s "maximalist" vision transforms the moors into a polished, high-fashion fantasy, and what happens when you swap out the novel’s brutal "otherness" for the glossy stardom of Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi. The result is beautiful. Seductive. And deeply at odds with the book’s warning about fantasy as a form of destruction. Go to http://greenchef.com/50THETAKE, use code 50THETAKE to get 50% off your first month Watch this video to spot the biggest shifts (Book vs Movie): The "Barbie-fication" of Cathy: How Margot Robbie’s performance turns a destructive, feral character into an "aesthetic" icon. Heathcliff and the "Ken" Problem: Why casting Jacob Elordi erases the critical racial identity and "othering" that fuels Heathcliff’s revenge. A World Without Heirs: The impact of removing the entire second generation (and Hindley) to focus purely on a toxic, anachronistic love triangle. Soundtrack vs. Story: Does Charli xcx’s electronic score enhance the obsession, or just defang the horror? If you love deep dives into what you're watching, like literary tropes and cinematic style, subscribe to The Take! #WutheringHeights2026 #EmeraldFennell #MargotRobbie #JacobElordi #TheTake #EmilyBronte #FilmAnalysis #VideoEssay #GothicHorror #CharliXCX #BookVsMovie CHAPTERS 00:00 Intro: “Beautiful… But Wrong” 01:55 Thanks to Green Chef 03:08 Cathy Becomes Barbie: Robbie's Aesthetic Influence 07:11 Heathcliff as “Ken:" The Controversy of Erasure 10:42 Defanged: Sex, Sanitization & Lost Horror. Why the Violence and Vengeance Matter. 14:20 Barbie Cannot Be a Mother: Why The 2nd Generation Cut Undermines the Story (The Ending Change) 18:45 Conclusion: Is it an Adaptation or an Dangerous Imitation? Follow our socials: https://linktr.ee/thisisthetake Read more on film & culture: https://www.the-take.com CREDITS Created by Debra Minoff & Susannah McCullough Written by Ellie Slee Narration by Charly Bivona Edited by John Todd Produced by Nick Vasile