Marty’s Pizza Has Been Around Since 1957… But Is It Actually Good?

#MartysPIzza #JamesEatsFood #DelafieldWI #MilwaukeeFood Marty's Pizza 2580 Sun Valley Dr Delafield, WI 53018 Phone: (262) 646-3327 Menu: martyspizzadelafield.com   / martysdelafield     / martysdelafield   My Eastern Wisconsin pizza tour continues at Marty’s Pizza in Delafield, a local Wisconsin pizza spot that has been around since 1957. In this Marty’s Pizza Delafield review, I’m checking out the menu, the pizza sizes, the service, and whether this long-running local favorite still holds up today. For this visit, I ordered the pepperoni pizza, Marty’s homemade cheese breadsticks, and the buffalo chicken pizza. Marty’s Pizza does things a little differently compared to standard round-pie pizza restaurants. Their pizzas are served in squares and rectangles, and they also offer larger catering-style sizes for bigger groups. They also price their pizzas by the ingredient, which gives the menu a very old-school, local-pizza feel. 0:00 Marty's Pizza Delafield 1:11 Marty's Pizza Delafield Menu 2:08 Marty’s Pizza Sizes 2:30 Pepperoni Pizza 5:01 Marty’s Homemade Cheese Breadsticks 6:56 Buffalo Chicken Pizza 8:44 Is Marty’s Pizza in Delafield Good? 9:24Totinos Party Pizza Comparison Email: [email protected] The pepperoni pizza was solid, but the pepperoni quality left me wanting more from a sit-down pizza restaurant. The buffalo chicken pizza was a better option, with moist chicken and familiar buffalo flavor. The cheese breadsticks were serviceable, but not something I would go out of my way to order again. Overall, Marty’s Delafield offers great service, a friendly atmosphere, high-quality cheese, and a unique Wisconsin party-pizza style. But is Marty’s Pizza Wisconsin good enough to drive across the state for, or is it better as a strong local pizza roulette option? I also compare Marty’s Pizza to a premium version of Totino’s Party Pizza, which may sound strange, but it makes sense once you see the crust and square-cut style.