'Fake' Ransom Notes: FBI Says Some Demands May Be Real? | Nancy Guthrie Missing

The Nancy Guthrie case just got even more confusing, as the FBI is now pushing back on reports that every alleged ransom note tied to Savannah Guthrie’s missing mother was fake. Reuters reported that FBI sources believe all of the ransom-related messages are bogus, but TMZ’s Harvey Levin says his FBI contacts are telling him something very different: that some of the original ransom demands may still be considered potentially legitimate. In this episode of Drop Dead Serious, Ashleigh Banfield breaks down the chaos over the Nancy Guthrie ransom notes, the FBI’s new statement saying the case is still being investigated as a kidnapping for ransom, the role of the Pima County Sheriff’s Department, and why the alleged messages sent to media outlets have become such a critical and controversial part of the investigation. Ashleigh is joined by James Hamilton, former FBI Supervisory Special Agent and founder of Hamilton Security Group, to discuss how investigators evaluate ransom demands, why different FBI sources may be giving different assessments, and what this latest twist means for the search for Nancy Guthrie. Check out Particle’s Face Cream here: https://particleformen.co/banfield and use my code BANFIELD20 for a 20% discount sitewide. Join The Dead Serious Club:    / @dropdeadserious   Drop Dead Serious is available on all podcast platforms. Follow on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast... Follow on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/5Dndaie... Check out the Merch! https://shop.dropdeadserious.com/ Follow Ashleigh on Social Media Instagram:   / ashleighbanfield     / dropdeadseriouspodcast   TikTok:   / tvashleigh     / dropdeadseriouspodcast   Facebook:   / ashleighbanfield   Website: https://www.dropdeadserious.com/ Drop Dead Serious is a true crime and legal commentary podcast produced for informational and entertainment purposes. The views expressed by our hosts and guests are their own and do not constitute legal advice or professional counsel. All persons discussed are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. We rely on publicly available sources, verified reporting, and official records, but we cannot guarantee all information is free from errors or omissions. Viewer discretion is advised. Some content may be protected under Fair Use (17 U.S. Code § 107) for the purposes of commentary, criticism, and news reporting. Any sponsorships or affiliate links will be disclosed when applicable. Nancy Guthrie Ransom Note Chaos: FBI Says Some Demands May Be Real | Nancy Guthrie Missing ashleigh banfield,ashleigh banfield podcast,drop dead serious,drop dead serious podcast,true crime podcast,ashleigh banfield true crime,true crime,true crime cases,true crime stories,crime stories,nancy guthrie,nancy guthrie ransom note,nancy guthrie missing,nancy guthrie missing update,nancy guthrie news,nancy guthrie case,ashleigh banfield nancy guthrie,nancy guthrie ransom note fake,nancy guthrie ransom note real

LIVE COURT | O'Keefe v. Read - Emergency Hearing - The Wrongful Death case pops off.
▶︎

LIVE COURT | O'Keefe v. Read - Emergency Hearing - The Wrongful Death case pops off.

Nancy Guthrie-Mac McCollum joins and she minces no words about the notes.
▶︎

Nancy Guthrie-Mac McCollum joins and she minces no words about the notes.

'Almost Feral': The shocking Ohio abuse case involving 16 children, what we know so far
▶︎

'Almost Feral': The shocking Ohio abuse case involving 16 children, what we know so far

Morning News NOW Full Episode – July 2
▶︎

Morning News NOW Full Episode – July 2

Officers Traumatized By The Worst House Of Horrors They Have Ever Seen
▶︎

Officers Traumatized By The Worst House Of Horrors They Have Ever Seen

LIVE TUCSON Nancy Guthrie Case - Derrick Callella Federal Court Hearing | 857 Tucson
▶︎

LIVE TUCSON Nancy Guthrie Case - Derrick Callella Federal Court Hearing | 857 Tucson

Brian Hooker’s ex claims he threatened she would have an ‘accident’ in new report- where is Lynette?
▶︎

Brian Hooker’s ex claims he threatened she would have an ‘accident’ in new report- where is Lynette?

Are Nancy Guthrie notes fake or real? Latest from sources, plus update on DNA
▶︎

Are Nancy Guthrie notes fake or real? Latest from sources, plus update on DNA

Chilling ransom note: ‘Hello Savannah. We have your mother, Nancy’ | Drop Dead Serious
▶︎

Chilling ransom note: ‘Hello Savannah. We have your mother, Nancy’ | Drop Dead Serious

Nancy Guthrie Update: Are Investigators Looking at a Real Kidnapping?
▶︎

Nancy Guthrie Update: Are Investigators Looking at a Real Kidnapping?

FULL MKULTRA HEARING: CIA'S MKUltra Program Probed By Lawmakers Seeking Answers About 'Mind Control'
▶︎

FULL MKULTRA HEARING: CIA'S MKUltra Program Probed By Lawmakers Seeking Answers About 'Mind Control'

The Briefing With Jen Psaki 7/2/26 | 🅼🆂🅽🅱️🅲 Breaking News Today July 2, 2026
▶︎

The Briefing With Jen Psaki 7/2/26 | 🅼🆂🅽🅱️🅲 Breaking News Today July 2, 2026

New! Hitman Hired by Infamous Adelson Family Writes Apology Letter to Victim's Family
▶︎

New! Hitman Hired by Infamous Adelson Family Writes Apology Letter to Victim's Family

Nancy Guthrie: Why so many believe Tomasso and Annie are responsible for what happened to Nancy.
▶︎

Nancy Guthrie: Why so many believe Tomasso and Annie are responsible for what happened to Nancy.

The Newest TARGET IN IRAN Just Got Revealed And No One Saw It Coming
▶︎

The Newest TARGET IN IRAN Just Got Revealed And No One Saw It Coming

VIDEO OF NANCY GUTHRIE & KIDNAPPER CLAIM
▶︎

VIDEO OF NANCY GUTHRIE & KIDNAPPER CLAIM

Profiting from the Presidency: Trump and Family Rake In Billions from Crypto, Real Estate & More
▶︎

Profiting from the Presidency: Trump and Family Rake In Billions from Crypto, Real Estate & More

🔴 BREAKING - COURT HEARING! DERRICK CALLELLA!! NANCY GUTHRIE KIDNAPPING - LIVE
▶︎

🔴 BREAKING - COURT HEARING! DERRICK CALLELLA!! NANCY GUTHRIE KIDNAPPING - LIVE

Nancy Guthrie Case: What Could Derrick Callella's Court Hearing Reveal This Week?
▶︎

Nancy Guthrie Case: What Could Derrick Callella's Court Hearing Reveal This Week?

Investigator: Guthrie ransom notes are 'bogus' | Jesse Weber Live
▶︎

Investigator: Guthrie ransom notes are 'bogus' | Jesse Weber Live