The Guinness Alternative Everyone Ignores… But Should They?

If you enjoyed the Guinness Alternative Index Episode 5 video, please consider subscribing to my channel. Cheers! 🍻 This has been sat on supermarket shelves for years… and yet no one really talks about it as a Guinness alternative. Siren’s Broken Dream is a nitro stout — so on paper, it absolutely belongs in the Guinness Alternative Index. But with its coffee profile and slightly different approach, it’s always felt like it sits just outside the conversation. So the question is simple — does that make it a worse Guinness alternative… or a better one? In this episode of the Guinness Alternative Index, I put Broken Dream through the full process — hard pour vs nitro, scoring it properly against the same criteria as every other stout in the series. Because if this deserves a place on the leaderboard… we might have all been overlooking it. Let’s find out. 📊 This is Episode 5 of the Guinness Alternative Index — where we test nitro stouts against Guinness using a consistent scoring system. If there’s another stout you want added to the Guinness Alternative Index, drop it in the comments — the leaderboard is just getting started. #Guinness #IrishStout #beerreview Click here for the original Mulligan's Irish Stout vs Guinness video:    • Aldi Mulligan’s Irish Stout vs Guinness | ...   Click here for more of my craft beer reviews;    / @thecrumbybeard