What is Tyler Hynes' Best Movie? Find Out Here.

Every Tyler Hynes Hallmark movie — all 25 of them — ranked from worst to best. Before we even get to the top five, I'm dropping a ranking that's going to have some of you putting down your coffee and staring at the screen. It Was Always You fans, you've been warned. Why the Groomsmen trilogy — all three movies — was a misfire that even Tyler couldn't save, and the one scene from a completely different movie where he outperformed his entire Groomsmen run. The Tyler Hynes and Rhiannon Fish chemistry in A Picture of Her that I can only describe as: put your safety glasses on, because these two were not acting Why I actually like Never Been Kissed more than most Heinies do — and why Tyler deserves credit for taking that risk even if Hallmark chickened out at the ending. Where It Was Always You lands — and why I think its central premise has always had a problem that even Erin Krakow and Tyler can't fully paper over Why An Unexpected Christmas with Bethany Joy Lenz is, in my opinion, Tyler Hynes' single best Hallmark movie — and why the runner-up genuinely surprised even me. CHAPTERS 0:00 – Intro: Tyler Hynes and the King of the Passionate Kiss 1:30 – The Two You Can Skip: Groomsmen First Look & Second Chance 3:00 – Wedding March 5, Mistletoe Secret & the Movies Tyler Couldn't Save 5:30 – A Controversial Take on Time for Him to Come Home for Christmas 7:00 – Hollywood Touchdown, Christmas Above the Clouds & the Erin Krakow Question 9:00 – Three Wise Men, Shifting Gears & the Lacey Chabert Pairing Problem 11:00 – Safety Glasses Required: Tyler & Rhiannon Fish in A Picture of Her 12:30 – Always Amore, Flip That Romance & Never Been Kissed 14:30 – It Was Always You: Why It Just Missed the Top 5 16:00 – The Top 5: It's Christmas Eve, Roadhouse Romance & On the 12th Day of Christmas 17:30 – #1: Why An Unexpected Christmas Is Tyler Hynes' Best Movie Be honest — did you see An Unexpected Christmas coming at #1, or were you absolutely convinced It Was Always You had the top spot locked? SUBSCRIBE New episodes every week — subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive. HASHTAGS #tylerhynes #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkChannel #AnUnexpectedChristmas #ItWasAlwaysYou #APictureOfHer #BethanyJoyLenz #ErinKrakow #RhiannonFish #LaceyChabert #HallmarkRanking #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #ChristmasMovies #RomanceMovies #Hynies