I Tested Claude Design vs Remotion vs HyperFrames. The Winner Wasn't Expected

I called Claude Design the most robotic-looking of the three. Then I shuffled the labels, went blind, and gave it three straight wins without knowing. Six identical prompts across Claude Design, Remotion, and HyperFrames, no After Effects, every render timed on screen. Then a second judge scored the same clips and picked opposite winners. By the end I knew which tool fits which shot.