Y Religion Episode 145: “Thou Shalt Utterly Destory” Understanding the Biblical Hērem

(David Calabro) What do we make of times in scripture where violence occurs, especially when the destruction comes because of God’s commands? In this episode, Professor David M. Calabro discusses his article “‘Thou Shalt Utterly Destroy’: Understanding the Biblical Ḥērem”, which grapples with the troubling and often misunderstood concept of ḥērem—the ritualized devotion of people, cities, and goods to God that appears in the conquest narratives of Deuteronomy and Joshua. Calabro explains that while ḥērem is frequently read today as indiscriminate violence or genocide, its ancient meaning is far more complex. Rooted linguistically in ideas of holiness and consecration, ḥērem reflects an ancient Near Eastern way of framing warfare in theological, often hyperbolic terms. By placing Israel’s scriptures alongside archaeological evidence, inscriptions from neighboring cultures, and restored gospel truths, the episode shows how biblical language of total destruction functioned within a shared cultural hyperbolic idiom, and that ḥērem is not ultimately about ethnicity or nationality, but about covenant loyalty, repentance, and one’s response to God. Rather than resolving all moral and theological questions, Calabro’s work invites listeners to read these texts with greater historical awareness, humility, and a willingness to work with God to understand His ways. Y Religion podcast episodes are available every two weeks and can be found on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Podcasts, Stitcher, Pandora, and on the web at https://rsc.byu.edu/media/y-religion