Karen Read’s Retrial: Did Investigators Get John O’Keefe’s Death Wrong? | Part 2

In Part 2 of our series on the Karen Read case, we move from the backstory into the high-stakes retrial of John O’Keefe’s death. This episode follows the courtroom day by day, from opening statements and emotional witness testimonies to disputed taillight evidence, cell phone data, and questions about the integrity of the investigation. With conflicting accounts, surprising revelations, and experts who can’t agree, the retrial leaves the jury and the public facing more questions than answers about what really happened that night. Some crimes are solved by a single clue — one overlooked fingerprint, a missing puzzle piece, or a detail hiding in plain sight. Clues, a Crime House Original from PAVE Studios, takes you deep into the world of notorious crimes and forensic breakthroughs. If you're obsessed with forensic twists, cold cases, and the relentless pursuit of justice— hit subscribe and uncover your next true crime obsession. New video episodes drop every Wednesday! #Clues #CluesPodcast #MorganAbsher #KaelynMoore #Crime #CrimePodcast #karenread #johnokeefe #PAVEStudios Chapters: 0:00 Welcome to Clues Pod 2:37 Recap of Part One & Case Background 5:44 Jury Selection & Opening Statements 10:31 First Witnesses, Family Testimony & Text Messages 17:20 Jury Visits The Crime Scene 19:13 John's Phone Data & Google Searches 23:20 Jennifer McCabe’s Testimony 29:19 More Testimonies and Karen’s 50 Calls 33:25 Police Bias & Brian Higgins Connection 40:04 Surveillance Footage & Tail Light 42:53 DNA Evidence & Autopsy Findings 46:38 Vehicle Data & Expert Testimony 50:28 Accident Reconstruction & Dog Bite Theory 56:03 Tail Light Damage Discrepancy & Snowplow Driver Testimony 1:00:14 Strange ‘Butt Dial’ Phone Calls 1:05:50 Case Verdict 1:06:24 Final Thoughts 1:15:56 Missing Person of the Week: Jonathan Hoang Subscribe to never miss a moment!:    / @cluespod   ABOUT CLUES: Hosted by Morgan Absher and Kaelyn Moore, Clues unpacks the cases that gripped the world—from chilling murders to serial killers. Each episode dissects the evidence, retraces investigative breakthroughs, and follows the trail of clues that cracked the case—or left it hauntingly unsolved. Clues is a Crime House original, powered by PAVE Studios. WHERE TO LISTEN: Spotify – https://open.spotify.com/show/0EdKvs7... Apple – https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast... STAY CONNECTED WITH CLUES: Instagram:   / cluespodcast   Follow Morgan:   / morgsyabsher   Follow Kaelyn:   / itskaelynmoore   ============================= Copyright Notice: This video and my YouTube channel contain dialog, music, and images that are property of Clues Podcast. You are authorized to share the video link and channel, and embed this video in your website or others as long as a link back to my YouTube Channel is provided. © 2025 Clues Podcast Karen Read’s Retrial P2: Did Investigators Get John O’Keefe’s Death Wrong? | Clues Pod    / @cluespod