Broadway First Dates: Michael McKean and Annette O'Toole

Before they had even gone on their first date, Annette O'Toole and Michael McKean knew their relationship was blessed by the (Shoe) Lord. And before they'd even kissed, they were clinging to each other at a Van Morrison concert. The couple's history is a story of true love that came when both parties were least expecting it — a story that O'Toole says she hopes is "hopeful to people." Because sometimes your future is just a post-ER phone call away.