Метро теперь только для Москвы. Судьба метротрама Красноярска и метро в России

Related videos How St. Petersburg Forgot How to Build a Metro:    • Как Петербург разучился строить метро. Ист...   How the Moscow Metro Was Ruined? Sobyanin's Records, New Stations in Fields, and the Cult of Simplification    • Как испортили метро Москвы? Рекорды Собяни...   Your City Doesn't Need a Metro! How the Tram Became Better than the Metro – the Hanover Metrotram:    • Как трамвай стал лучше метро — метротрам Г...   Is Public Transportation Only for the Poor? Residents Against the Zurich Metro:    • Городской транспорт только для бедных? Про...   How Much Does a Good Tram Cost? The Rebirth of the Taganrog Tram:    • Сколько стоит хороший трамвай? Перерождени...   Problems with the Volgograd Metrotram:    • Метротрам Волгограда: почему отказались от...   -------- I remember well how, on my way to kindergarten, a fence with a bright red letter M on it appeared—this was the main construction site of the Krasnoyarsk metro. Soon we'll have a metro like Moscow, I thought! And here I am, 31 years old, and there's still no metro in Krasnoyarsk, but the dream project of a Krasnoyarsk subway hasn't been abandoned—now they're building a metrotram there! And today we'll talk about this project. More precisely, using this project as an example, we'll discuss urban planning in general and transport economics, debunk the Soviet myth about the need for a metro in Russian cities with a population of over a million, and what alternatives there are to saving a large city from traffic jams. -------- For collaboration inquiries: [email protected] Support the project team: ✅ Boosty (for Russian cards): https://boosty.to/gershman ✅ Telegram (any card): https://t.me/gre4ark/21130 ✅ YouTube sponsorship (for international cards): youtube.com/arkadiygershman/join ✅ Patreon (for international cards):   / gershman   -------- Telegram: https://t.me/gre4ark TikTok: https://vm.tiktok.com/ZSJEse2Gf/ Twitter:   / arkadiygershman   VK: http://vk.com/gre4ark FB:   / gre4ark   Instagram:   / gre4ark   Blog With text posts: http://urbanblog.ru -------- My name is Arkady Gershman, and for the last ten years I've been promoting a healthy attitude toward the city (google "City for People"). Simply put, I'm an urbanist with an unhealthy love of transportation. I'm not an architect, so I won't talk about the choice of materials or different architectural styles, but I will talk about proper urban planning policies, how to lay a tram, what a street should look like, and how to create a park without drug addicts and alcoholics. -------- Timecodes: 00:00 Hello! Let's talk about the metro? 01:33 Soviet plans for the metro 04:07 The first construction of the Krasnoyarsk metro 05:05 Moscow versus the metro and the Russian economy 06:51 Conditions for metro construction 09:20 Heavy and light transport in the city 11:03 Will the tram alone be enough? 1:57 PM Krasnoyarsk Metro + Tram (Metrotram) 3:22 PM Problems with the New Project 4:37 PM Two Troubles of Krasnoyarsk 7:06 PM Construction and Ticket Prices 10:02 PM Option 1 - Metro and a Little Tram 11:48 PM Option 2 - A Normal Metrotram 8:10 PM Option 3 - A Modern Tram 8:42 PM What's your choice?