Caller Says ‘It’s Not About Trans’… Then Proves It Is | Jimmy Snow + Luxander

Idris calls in to argue that trans women have an unfair biological advantage in women’s sports, but his position crumbles once the specifics are laid out. Jimmy and Luxander start by pointing out that you can’t measure “pure biology” when girls’ and women’s sports are chronically underfunded, undercoached, and under-resourced from childhood through the Olympic level, so any apparent performance gap is distorted by money and opportunity, not just bodies. They then narrow the conversation to what actually matters: not “average men vs average women,” but elite athletes and trans women whose performance already sits at the extreme ends of their categories. When Idris insists this “isn’t about trans issues,” Jimmy presents a sharp hypothetical: suppose a trans woman’s puberty is managed with estrogen such that her height, muscle mass, and other metrics fall fully within the normal female range—would Idris then allow her to compete? Even in that scenario, Idris says it should still “depend on the sport,” revealing that his objection isn’t really about data or fairness, but about never truly accepting trans women as women in the spaces they want to be. Patreon - https://jimmyasnow.com/Patreon Join my Twitch Community:   / jimmyalexandersnow   Join my Discord Community: Coming Soon! Join my Reddit Community: Coming Soon! The Line:    / thelinecallinshows   ----------------------------------------------- **Support the Channel** Patreon - https://jimmyasnow.com/Patreon (Be my hero!) Merch: http://jimmyasnow.com/Merch Become A Channel Member- https://jimmyasnow.com/member Paypal - https://jimmyasnow.com/Paypal Venmo- @Jimmy-Snow-5 Amazon Wishlist: https://jimmyasnow.com/Wishlist Audible- Trial- https://amzn.to/2NHjV7K (2 Free Books) ---------------------------------------------------- Twitch: http://jimmyasnow.com/twitch Instagram - http://jimmyasnow.com/instagram Contact - [email protected] -------------------------------------------------- Send Mail, Gifts, and Packages The Line 110 N Interstate 35 Suite 315-1027 Round Rock, TX 78681