Может ли ДПС остановить просто для проверки документов в 2024 г.? Причина остановки ДПС

Mining Channel - https://youtube.com/@user-wr1pd2ow1c?... -------------------- ✔ Telegram Group - https://t.me/typrav ✔ Viber Group - https://invite.viber.com/?g2=AQAeFF08... ✔ WhatsApp Group - https://chat.whatsapp.com/FLSzkdO7xOL... ✔ VK Group - https://vk.com/public186537967 -------------------- Can traffic police stop a car and check documents without cause? Do they have the right to do this? In this video, we'll discuss whether a traffic police officer has the right to stop you anywhere to check your documents. Until 2017, Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs Order No. 185 was in effect. Clause 65 stated that the basis for a traffic police officer's stopping a vehicle was a document check for the driver's license. It also clarified that this basis only applies at stationary traffic police posts. In 2017, this order was repealed due to the adoption of a new Order No. 664 by the Ministry of Internal Affairs. After reading this order, many drivers and lawyers concluded that traffic police officers no longer have the right to simply stop a vehicle to check documents. I'll explain their reasoning. The list of grounds for a traffic police officer to demand that a driver stop a vehicle is provided in Clause 84 of the Administrative Regulations. It contains as many as 14 grounds for stopping a vehicle. According to subparagraph 84.13 of the Administrative Regulations, the grounds for a traffic police officer to request a driver to stop a vehicle are: - Checking the vehicle's operating documents, vehicle documents, and the cargo being transported. However, in this same regulation, there is paragraph 106, which lists four grounds for document checks: Identifying signs of a traffic violation; The presence of a warrant or information about the driver's involvement in an accident or crime, or suspicion that the vehicle is wanted; Carrying out accident prevention measures; And the last and most important point is stopping a vehicle for the reasons specified in subparagraphs 84.1, 84.2, 84.3, and 84.11 of the Administrative Regulations. As you can see, the last paragraph makes no mention of paragraph 84.13. Consequently, many have concluded that a traffic police officer does not have the right to simply stop a car to check documents. However, judicial practice took a different path, and courts in these cases upheld vehicle stops based on Section 84.13 as lawful. Links to several similar cases are provided in the video description; anyone interested can view them. The Supreme Court settled this dispute. At the end of 2017, a hero of our time, a certain Konstantin Pavlovich Rudakov, filed a lawsuit with the Supreme Court demanding that subsection 84.13 of the Administrative Regulations, which stipulates the possibility of stopping a vehicle for document checks outside of stationary checkpoints, be declared invalid, citing its contradiction with Part 1 of Article 56 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, Article 27.3 of the Code of Administrative Offenses, and, most importantly, Section 106 of the Administrative Regulations. Unfortunately, all of Konstantin Rudakov's arguments were rejected by the court, and he lost the case. Regarding the contradiction between paragraph 84.13 and paragraph 106 of the Administrative Regulations, the court ruled that Rudakov's argument regarding the contradiction between these paragraphs is legally irrelevant, given that both provisions are different parts of the same legal act and have equal legal force. This Supreme Court decision has become a benchmark for all Russian courts, despite the obvious confusion within the Administrative Regulations. A link to this court decision is in the description of this video. Thus, it can be concluded that the Administrative Regulations, approved by Order No. 664 of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, allow traffic police officers to stop a vehicle outside of a stationary post for document checks. Therefore, police officers have the right to stop a vehicle for document checks anywhere. If you didn't know this, be sure to send this video to your friends so they can watch it, as... 99% of all articles and videos on YouTube claim that traffic police don't have the right to stop vehicles to check documents, and that they are deceiving people, which can lead to very bad results, as the courts have a different position. The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation's decision card - https://vsrf.ru/lk/practice/cases/981... The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation's decision itself - http://vsrf.ru/stor_pdf.php?id=1625448 Decision No. 1 - https://sudact.ru/regular/doc/bvNtmjQ... Decision No. 2 - https://sudact.ru/regular/doc/ypzYFHZ... Friends, we received comments from YouTube for posting links to other court decisions. As soon as we appeal these comments, we will post the removed links. #dps #gibdd #police