The Most Satisfying Blindsides in Survivor History

The most satisfying blindsides in Survivor history, ranked: 10. Randy Bailey plays a fake idol — Gabon 9. Drew Christy throws a challenge and goes home the same night — San Juan del Sur 8. Kat Edorsson: "blindsides are fun" — One World 7. Chris Noble voted out with an idol in his pocket — Ghost Island 6. Natalie Anderson's payback for Jeremy (Jon Misch) — San Juan del Sur 5. Jay blindsides Michaela the night before the merge — Millennials vs Gen X 4. Tyson votes himself out — Heroes vs Villains 3. Malcolm's two-idol Three Amigos play (Phillip Sheppard) — Caramoan 2. The Black Widow Brigade blindsides Ozzy with an idol unplayed — Micronesia 1. Kelley Wentworth's idol negates NINE votes (Andrew Savage) — Cambodia Every one of these was engineered — someone built the trap, and the victim walked in. We break down who built each one, why the victim never saw it, and why Kelley Wentworth's 9-vote idol play (still the record for most votes negated by an idol) is the most satisfying Tribal Council ever filmed. Who do you really trust? ▶ The Smartest Move in Every Survivor Season: [PASTE VIDEO 1 LINK] Chapters 0:00 The nine votes that vanished 0:47 #10 Randy and the fake idol 1:35 #9 Drew throws a challenge… at himself 2:23 #8 "Blindsides are fun" 3:05 #7 The Noble One falls 3:54 #6 "This is payback for Jeremy" 4:41 #5 The night before the merge (Michaela) 5:51 #4 Tyson votes out Tyson 6:53 #3 Two idols and Three Amigos 7:41 #2 The Black Widow Brigade gets Ozzy 8:35 #1 Nine votes, zero survivors 9:36 The pattern All footage used under fair use for commentary and criticism. Survivor is a CBS production.