Editor critiques the first page of a Cyberpunk novel!
Ever wonder what an editor or agent is thinking about as they read through the opening pages of a manuscript? Now you can find out! In this real-time critique of the first page of a Science Fiction (Cyberpunk) manuscript, I'll talk about what the writer does well, what they can work on in their next round of revisions, and explain my logic so (hopefully!) it can be a positive learning experience for all of us. Where do I get these pages? First page critiques are a new segment I'm offering to my patrons. That means this page was written by a living, breathing human. While I'll welcome craft discussion in the comments section, please keep it constructive and kind. Yes, writers need to have a thick skin for critique, but that doesn't mean we get to be careless with our feedback. Is this really how I edit? Yes! The primary difference between this video and my edits is how I'm communicating my thoughts. In an actual edit, I'd make note of my feedback either in the margins or in the notes for my editorial letter. Ready to read with me? Let's get started! -Cee ✨ Your support keeps this channel going: / ceemtaylor ________________________________ Want me to take a look at your prose? I do short & sweet substantive edits on the first 5k words of manuscripts for authors looking for help with their writing (or help polishing for querying). You can learn more about 5k Passes here: https://www.cameronmontaguetaylor.com... ________________________________ ✍ Resources ✍ 🌟 GET BONUS CONTENT + SUPPORT THE CHANNEL: ( / ceemtaylor ) 🧾 WORK WITH A PRO EDITOR ON YOUR MANUSCRIPT: https://www.cameronmontaguetaylor.com... 📘 GET MY NOVEL PLANNING GUIDE: https://www.etsy.com/listing/13737830... 💌 CHECK OUT THE NEWSLETTER (DON'T MISS AN UPDATE!): https://www.cameronmontaguetaylor.com... 📚 READ MY STORIES: https://www.cameronmontaguetaylor.com... 🧙♂️ FOLLOW 🧙♂️ bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/ceemtaylor.b... tiktok: / ceemtaylor patreon: / ceemtaylor 🔮 ABOUT ME 🔮 Hi! I'm Cameron Montague “Cee” Taylor. As a freelance developmental editor, I set out to help my authors navigate their edits while staying true to their creative vision. When I'm not hard at work on my clients' manuscripts, I'm pecking away at my own. I write Fantasy set in far-flung worlds with LGBTQIA+ heroes and strong romantic subplots. When I don’t have a pen in hand, you can find me on the water, underwater, or desperately trying to keep my houseplants alive.🪴 #howtowriteprose #writingtips #writingadvice #howtowriteabook #sciencefictionnovel

Watch a pro editor line edit in real-time!📝

Why Most Sci-Fi/Fantasy Drafts Fall Apart by Chapter 3

Editor critiques the first page of a Fantasy manuscript in real-time!

My Subscribers Sent Me Their Manuscripts…They ALL Make This Mistake

Why Most Writers Overwrite — And How to Fix It Without Losing Your Voice

I'm an Editor. Here Are 7 Signs Your Book Will Flop.

First Page MISTAKES New Writers Make ❌ avoid these cringey clichés!

The 3 Decisions that DEFINE your writing voice with Alan Moore | Meet your Maestro | BBC Maestro

The Myth of the ‘Brilliant’ Idea

Ranking Writing Tools: The Good, The Bad, and the Scams

Does Your Novel Pass My First Page Test?

The Truth About Publishing a Book in 2026 (From Macmillan’s CEO)

5 Magic System Mistakes That Will Cost You Readers

Misusing this popular sentence structure can muck up your prose 😳

I’m an Editor and These Are the 7 First-Draft Mistakes I See All the Time

I Discovered The Perfect AI Writing System (Life-Changing)

Edit like a pro by MAPPING your novel!

First Draft MISTAKES New Writers Make ❌ Avoid these common pitfalls!

I'm a Book Editor. AI Novels Make Me Furious.

