Herb Baumeister | Indiana's Worst Serial Killer and the I70 Strangler

In the 1980s, men started disappearing in Indiana and Ohio. Some bodies were discovered in ditches and other areas near I70 while others seemed to vanish into thin air. Police brushed off the disappearances as being due to the victims' gay lifestyles. When a private investigator and determined detective refused to give up on their hunch that a serial killer was targeting gay men, it led to a horrific discovery on an estate. Someone who is believed to be Indiana’s worst serial killer. If you have a Midwest case suggestion, please leave a comment! I love hearing about new cases to research. Thank you so much for watching! Resources: “You Think You Know Me: The True Story of Herb Baumeister and the Horror at Fox Hollow Farm” by Ryan Green, 2018 Herb Baumeister: Serial Killer    • Herb Baumeister: Serial Killer l WTHR Special   Investigative Reports episode:    • The Killer Who Buried Secrets in His Backy...   What we know about Herb Baumeister    • What we know about notorious serial killer...   https://www.wcpo.com/news/crime/herb-... Forgotten at Fox Hollow    • WRTV Presents: Forgotten at Fox Hollow, th...   Real History episode:    • Video   Crime Stories episode:    • Herb Baumeister Case   Bones discovered    • WISHstory: Bones discovered at Fox Hollow ...   Coroner breaks down docuseries    • Coroner breaks down Fox Hollow murders doc...   https://indyencyclopedia.org/herbert-... https://www.newsweek.com/fox-hollow-m... https://www.indystar.com/story/news/l... https://www.indystar.com/picture-gall... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herb_Ba... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I-70_St... Police renew effort to find remains    • Police renew effort to find remains at Her...   Herb’s interview on raccoon    • Herb Baumeister: WISH-TV Archive files:   Former private investigator reveals how he cracked Herb Baumeister case    • Former private investigator reveals how he...   Police discuss Baumeister's double life    • Police discuss Baumeister's 'double life' ...   Tour of Fox Hollow 2022    • Tour of Fox Hollow, Herb Baumeister residence   Remains identified    • Remains of possible Herb Baumeister victim...   Mother of victim gets closure    • Mother of Herb Baumeister victim gets clos...   Remains identified    • Remains identified from serial killer Herb...   Searchers return to Baumeister property    • Searchers return to former Baumeister prop...   Coroner identifies new victim    • Coroner identifies new victim of alleged I...   Daughter of new victim speaks    • Daughter of new victim of alleged serial k...   GenGenies to help identify victims    • GenGenies to help identify Baumeister vict...   Docuseries examines Herb Baumeister    • New docuseries examines case of suspected ...   Victim of Herb Baumeister identified    • Victim of suspected serial killer Herb Bau...   Handcuffs and bones unearthed    • Handcuffs and bones unearthed at Fox Hollo...   Fox Hollow victims laid to rest    • Fox Hollow victims laid to rest   Memorial held for Fox Hollow Farm victims    • Memorial held for Fox Hollow Farm victims   The Gay 80s    • The Gay 80's :: Eyewitness News :: Archiva...   Pinery Provincial Park drone footage:    • Exploring Pinery Provincial Park By Drone ...   Indianapolis drone footage: •    • Downtown Day & Night - Indianapolis, India...   •    • Indianapolis Night Cinematic | 4K   •    • Drone footage of downtown Indianapolis sky...   •    • Indianapolis, Indiana 2025 - 4K Drone Foot...   •    • Indianapolis Skyline from I-70 4K Drone BROLL   •    • Indianapolis (August 2025) - 4K Drone Footage   💋 On my lips: Coloured Pop "Dopey" 🎶 End Song 🎶 Wayne Jones - "Please" Camera: Sony A6100 Editing Software: Filmora I try my best to thoroughly research and present the facts as best as I can. If anything I say is incorrect, it is not intentional. I also include common theories and my opinions. Those should not be construed as fact. All opinions expressed are my own. #midwesttruecrime #herbbaumeister #serialkiler