言語学者が炎上した。なぜ？

Why did linguist Whorf face backlash? We discussed criticisms of Whorf, including "Where is 'be going to' going?", "His methods are almost like Koume Tayu's," and "Why you should still read Whorf." [Supplement from the Supervisor] 8:37 While there's an explanation that "Hopi language indicates tense through aspect," if we consider Whorf's "manifested/manifesting" to be similar to "realis/irrealis," it seems better to understand it as indicating tense through mood. Since the present/past (non-future) is often associated with reality, and the future with unreality, this can be seen as a distinction close to tense opposition. [Table of Contents] 00:00 Where is 'be going to' going? 06:22 The "Ta" Episode Again 11:48 Whorf, the Comedian Theory 15:47 Doubts about the Hopi Language Research 20:18 Whorf's Hypothesis is Needed Now More Than Ever 30:25 Let's Talk About the Sci-Fi Film 'Arrival' [Reference Links] ◯Language, Thought, and Reality https://www.valuebooks.jp/bp/VS004601... ◯50 Thinkers of Language: A History of Linguistics Through the Eyes of Key Figures https://amzn.to/4b0ehHU ◯The Language and Mind of Second Language Users: Recommendations from a Multi-Competence Perspective https://amzn.to/4lgMIgZ ◯Language and Thought https://www.valuebooks.jp/bp/VS001707... ◯Different Languages ​​Make the World Look Different https://www.valuebooks.jp/bp/VS008280... ◯The Instinct That Creates Language (Part 1) https://www.valuebooks.jp/bp/VS000086... ◯What If There Were No "Right" or "Left"? An Invitation to Linguistic Anthropology https://www.valuebooks.jp/bp/VS004472... ◯ Language Cognition and Communication https://amzn.to/40kop8c ◯ Sapir's Theory of Linguistics https://amzn.to/40SY6WJ 【Books Mentioned】 ◯ 1% Effort https://amzn.to/4uTxS4v ◯ Guns, Germs, and Steel https://www.valuebooks.jp/bp/VS000369... ◯ Skill is Also a Part of Luck https://www.valuebooks.jp/bp/VS006658... ◯ Hopi Time https://amzn.asia/d/0j25UHh3 ◯All official merchandise from the Yuru Gakuto Radio series https://www.valuebooks.jp/shelf-items... [Join our supporter community here!] https://yurugengo.com/support [Our first book, "Language Swamp," is available here!] 】 https://www.valuebooks.jp/bp/VS005875... 【Mizuno's solo work, "Linguistics of 0.2 Seconds of Conversation"】 https://www.valuebooks.jp/bp/VS006335... 【Horimoto's solo work, "The Complete Guide to Dirty Jokes That Will Make You Smarter Just by Reading It"】 https://www.valuebooks.jp/bp/VS006333... 【Physical Store Project: Yuru Gakuto Cafe】    / @yurugakuto   【Sister Channel: Yuru Computer Science Radio】    / @yurucom   【We're on Twitter!】 Yuru Linguistics Radio has a Twitter account, so please follow us! You'll find interesting etymology stories and other content to satisfy your thirst for knowledge. →  / yuru_gengo   【Message Form】 https://forms.gle/mTGM7A9QNqgjZMgN7 *We look forward to receiving your fun messages! 【For Business Inquiries, Click Here!】 [email protected] 【Ken Horimoto Profile】 Graduated from Keio University, Faculty of Science and Technology. Majored in Information Engineering. Makes a living by creating and distributing theoretical content. Twitter→  / kenhori2   note Magazine→https://note.com/kenhori2/m/m125fc452... Personal YouTube→   / @kenhorimoto   【Taiki Mizuno Profile】 Born in 1995. From Aichi Prefecture. Graduated from Nagoya University, Faculty of Letters. Majored in Linguistics. Works as a magazine editor. Author of books such as "Linguistic Analysis of 0.2 Seconds of Conversation" (Shinchosha). She also hosts the podcast "Let's Meet in Jinbocho." Twitter → https://x.com/yuru_mizuno Let's Meet in Jinbocho → https://open.spotify.com/show/6cYkvDO... [BGM Provided by] ・Free BGM/Music Material MusMus https://musmus.main.jp ・OtoLogic https://otologic.jp/ #Sapir_Whorf_Hypothesis #YuruLinguisticsRadio_Sapir_Whorf_Hypothesis #Whorf #LinguisticRelativity #HopiLanguage #Controversy