Jets or Giants? Bart & Ty Go Head-to-Head in Heated Debate | Bart & Carlin - 7/14/26

The debate over New York football takes center stage as Bart Scott and Ty Butler go head-to-head over the future of the New York Jets and New York Giants. Bart argues that the Jets have more potential than the Giants heading into the season, while Ty strongly disagrees. The guys also break down the latest expectations for Jaxson Dart, debate roster ceilings, react to the Home Run Derby, discuss Juan Soto's interaction with Yankees All-Stars, and take plenty of calls from fans. Plus, Bart shares relationship advice on Ty's wedding anniversary, weighs in on the Jets offense, and closes the show with Jake Asman. Your home for all things New York sports — bringing you the energy, opinions, and insights that define the city’s sports scene. Weekday Lineup: DiPietro & Rothenberg — 6a-10a Bart & Carlin — 10a-1p The Michael Kay Show — 1p-3p Don, Hahn, & Rosenberg — 3p-7p Chapters: 0:00:00 Home Run Derby Reactions + Juan Soto Discussion 0:30:00 Bart Arrives + Ty's 5th Grade Prom Story 0:45:00 Bart & Ty Talk Jagged Edge 1:00:00 Ty's Anniversary + Jets vs Giants Debate Begins 1:30:00 Bart Doubles Down on the Jets Over the Giants 1:45:00 More Jets vs Giants Debate 2:00:00 Do the Jets Have More Potential Than the Giants? 2:30:00 Bart's Jaxson Dart Comparisons Continue 2:45:00 Jake Asman Joins the Show #ESPN #ESPNNewYork #NYsports #DiPietroAndRothenberg #BartAndCarlin #TheMichaelKayShow #donhahnrosenberg