Juan Ramón Rallo: El Principio de No Agresión, ¿un fundamento inestable?

In this revealing clip, Juan Ramón Rallo dissects the Non-Aggression Principle (NAP), arguing that its "incomplete specification" makes it an unstable foundation for political equilibrium. Rallo fundamentally questions who the rights holders are, ranging from adults and children to people with disabilities, animals, and robots, and highlights the lack of consensus on these subjects even among proponents of political anarchism. He then delves into the ambiguity of what exactly constitutes aggression, exploring examples such as blows, insults, defamation, threats, breach of contract, noise, odors, and even accidental trespassing or petty theft. Juan Ramón Rallo also addresses the complexity of the origin and transfer of property rights, challenging Loquean theory and questioning the requirements for the constitution and effective transfer of property. Finally, he examines the limits of rights, analyzing topics such as intellectual property and easements, as well as the establishment of compensation and the possible existence of positive rights. It concludes that the Non-Aggression Principle (NAP) is far from being a simple and self-evident principle, requiring a much broader consensus and detailed specification to serve as the foundation of a coherent legal and political system. 🔗 Link to the full conference:    • Juan Ramón Rallo - ¿Anarquismo o Minarqui...   Chapters: 00:00 Introduction 00:21 The First Problem: Incomplete Specification 00:32 Who Holds the Right to Non-Aggression? 02:56 The Second Problem: What Is Aggression? 03:00 Physical Assault 03:41 Insults, Defamation, and Threats 04:38 Breach of Contract 05:12 Noise, Odors, and Externalities 06:20 Humiliation, Harassment, Theft, and Invasion 07:26 When Do Rights Arise? (Property) 08:42 How Do We Transfer Property? 09:25 Contract Perfection 10:32 Limits of Rights 11:10 Intellectual Property 11:38 Easements 12:24 Compensation and Positive Rights 13:02 Conclusion: The PNA is not a simple principle ......... Help us continue and improve our work Become a member of the IJM: https://frapp.co/ngos/juandemariana/c... Become a member of the YouTube channel:    / @instjuandemariana   Make a donation: https://www.paypal.me/juandemariana Follow us on our social media Website - https://www.juandemariana.org Instagram -   / juandemariana   Facebook -   / juan.de.mariana   Twitter -   / juandemariana   LinkedIn -   / instituto-juan-de-mariana   Telegram - https://t.me/juandemariana