Ayetler Açıksa Hadise Ne İhtiyaç Var? Hadis İnkârcısı Mü’min Kalabilir mi? @ProfDrEbubekirSifil

If the Verses are Clear, What Need is There for Hadith? Can a Hadith Denier Remain a Believer? | Assoc. Prof. Dr. Kasım Takım & Prof. Dr. Ebu Bekir Sifil The statement, "The Quran is sufficient for me, I don't need hadith," has become increasingly common in recent years. But does this claim truly rest on the Quran? Or does it stem from a misunderstanding of the Quran? In this episode, Assoc. Prof. Dr. Kasım Takım (Biochemistry, Harran University) and Prof. Dr. Ebu Bekir Sifil (Theology) delve deeply into the Quranic, theological, and epistemological dimensions of hadith denial. The discussion covers critical topics such as the religious binding nature of hadiths, the foundations of the Sunnah in the Quran, the danger of historicism, and the ruling on deviating from the "path of the believers." Questions addressed in this video: — Why did God Almighty refer some rulings to the Sunnah instead of the Quran? — How does the Quran command obedience and adherence to the Prophet? — What does Ali's warning about the Kharijites mean for those who deny hadith? — Is the claim that the phrase "Allah and His Messenger" refers only to the verses of the Quran valid? — Is the Sunnah historical or universal? If the door of historicism is opened, would the rules of prayer and fasting also become invalid? — Can someone who denies hadith remain within the boundaries of faith? What is the theological answer to this question? Watch the issue of hadith denial, which is increasingly affecting more people in the contemporary Islamic world, through the eyes of two prominent figures from two different academic disciplines. 📌 This video is the 3rd episode of the hadith defense series on the "Creation in the Light of Sciences" channel. ⏱️ TIMELINE 0:00 Introduction – Episode 3 of the series and an overview of the issue of hadiths 0:09 Main question: Is accepting hadiths obligatory for Muslims, or is it optional? 0:28 Framing the claim "The Quran is sufficient for me, I don't need hadiths" 0:42 Prof. Sifil answers: How does the Quran guide us in our relationship with the Prophet? 1:10 "Obey Allah and His Messenger" – What these verses say to those who deny hadiths 2:27 Why did Allah refer some rulings to the Sunnah? The example of prayer and ablution 4:40 "Why is there a need for the Prophet?" Direct response to the objection 4:51 Refutation of the claim that "Every verse is explained by another verse in the Quran" 5:12 Verse 112 of Surah At-Tawbah: The expression "travelers" cannot be understood without the Sunnah 6:39 Example of the fasting verse in Surah Al-Baqarah: The Companions misunderstand the white and black threads, the Prophet corrects them 7:04 Fasting cannot be started without the Prophet's statement, and ablution and tayammum cannot be taught 7:19 The necessity of the Sunnah: Details not found in the Quran, from the rak'ahs of prayer to the rituals of Hajj 10:31 Hz. The lesson of Ali and the Kharijites: "They went astray by reading a verse of the Quran – I cannot convince you if you read a verse" 11:12 The multi-dimensional structure of the Quran: The danger of anyone being able to derive any meaning they want 11:34 The example of even Christians and Jews being admitted to paradise through ambiguous verses 14:00 The Quranic response to the claim that the expression "Allah and His Messenger" refers only to the Quran 16:37 Al-Ahzab 36th verse: When Allah and His Messenger have decreed, the believers have no choice 17:35 What happens if we say "I have a choice"? The severe warning in the continuation of the verse 18:07 The argument of the disbelievers that "The Prophet's statement cannot be anything other than revelation" and the answer 18:30 The claim that "There may be errors in the Prophet's interpretation": Hz. The Example of Omar and Hudaybiyyah 20:00 Why these arguments are invalid and the attitude of the Companions 25:06 The question, "The Prophet has passed away, what will we do?": The vitality of the Sunnah 25:37 The trap of historicism: If this door is opened, the commands of prayer and fasting also become invalid 28:51 Verse 115 of Surah An-Nisa: Opposition to the Prophet and deviating from the path of the believers deserves hell 29:28 Opposition to the Prophet is one thing, deviating from the path of the believers is another – two different crimes 32:02 Who is "the path of the believers"? Primarily the Companions and their understanding of the Quran and Sunnah 32:35 Was there ever an attitude among the Companions such as "this verse is historical, it does not bind us"? 39:05 The question of why the disbelievers did not take this verse into consideration 39:26 "When I heard this verse, I shuddered, I feared that I might be opposed to the path of the believers" – Prof. Sifil 39:41 Two concrete examples of how deniers interpret Surah An-Nisa 115: Mustafa İslamoğlu and Mehmet Okuyan 40:37 The question and explanation of why İslamoğlu did not write a long note on this verse 46:14 Unrecited revelation: Quranic evid...