The Odyssey of a Wine Critic with 'Vinous' Reviewer Joaquín Hidalgo

In this episode, we sit down with Joaquín Hidalgo — Buenos Aires-based wine journalist, Vinous reviewer, and the first Argentinean to join the international wine critic elite. Joaquín covers Argentina, Chile, Spain, and Portugal for Antonio Galloni's world renowned publication, Vinous, and has written for La Nación, Playboy and other local newspapers. We talk about his journey from winemaker to wine critic, his ironclad rules for integrity in a crumbling system, tasting with the world's best producers, and the only wine he ever gave 100 points. Joaquín also shares his thoughts on the rapidly evolving Argentine wine scene. This interview was filmed in Buenos Aires at Romanée Wine Experience (  / romaneeok  ) Timestamps: 0:02 — Introduction to Joaquín Hidalgo 3:18 — Origins in Mendoza and the Agricultural School 3:37 — From enologist to journalist 9:43 — First steps in wine journalism 12:07 — Integrity and independence as a critic 16:50 — The role of the critic and scores 17:32 — Tasting with producers and calibrating the palate 21:46 — Covering Spain for Vinous 27:25 — The wine that deserved 100 points 34:45 — Favorite regions in Argentina 42:30 — The Argentine DNA and the wine industry 49:00 — The rise of white wines in Argentina 52:02 — Wine consumption and the Buenos Aires market 59:21 — Pairings: the best wine for a barbecue 1:00:22 — The oldest wine and personal preferences 1:02:29 — Wines at home and favorite cocktail

La cara oculta de la sumillería: Alberto Ruffoni | The Wine Bunker #15
▶︎

La cara oculta de la sumillería: Alberto Ruffoni | The Wine Bunker #15

Why Your Wine Glass Matters with Riedel, The Wine Glass Company
▶︎

Why Your Wine Glass Matters with Riedel, The Wine Glass Company

Perfecting Taste with Nick Jackson, Master of Wine
▶︎

Perfecting Taste with Nick Jackson, Master of Wine

Prostitute Gives Me a Tour of the Red Light District
▶︎

Prostitute Gives Me a Tour of the Red Light District

Wine Spectator’s Top 10 of 2025 — What They Got RIGHT (and WRONG!)
▶︎

Wine Spectator’s Top 10 of 2025 — What They Got RIGHT (and WRONG!)

Rioja Paired | Episode 1: Marti | Basque Markets, Cuisine, and the Best Rioja Wines
▶︎

Rioja Paired | Episode 1: Marti | Basque Markets, Cuisine, and the Best Rioja Wines

Waste Not, Want Not: How Jancis Robinson Grew Up to Become the Most Respected Voice in Wine
▶︎

Waste Not, Want Not: How Jancis Robinson Grew Up to Become the Most Respected Voice in Wine

El camino hasta ser Master of Wine. Álvaro Ribalta | The Wine Bunker #8
▶︎

El camino hasta ser Master of Wine. Álvaro Ribalta | The Wine Bunker #8

The Rioja Carlos Calls “Iconic”
▶︎

The Rioja Carlos Calls “Iconic”

NY Times Wine Critic Talks About How He Learned About Wine
▶︎

NY Times Wine Critic Talks About How He Learned About Wine

Getting Into Wine: A Beginner's Crash Course
▶︎

Getting Into Wine: A Beginner's Crash Course

Out of Many, Único: Vega Sicilia CEO Pablo Álvarez on Legacy, Leadership, and the Modern Age
▶︎

Out of Many, Único: Vega Sicilia CEO Pablo Álvarez on Legacy, Leadership, and the Modern Age

How America’s 250th Looked From Europe (w/Jay Nordlinger) | Bulwark on Sunday
▶︎

How America’s 250th Looked From Europe (w/Jay Nordlinger) | Bulwark on Sunday

Learn To See What God Sees When He Looks At You
▶︎

Learn To See What God Sees When He Looks At You

Wine Pros Discuss & Taste: BORDEAUX vs BURGUNDY (with Andrew Jefford & Aigars Nords)
▶︎

Wine Pros Discuss & Taste: BORDEAUX vs BURGUNDY (with Andrew Jefford & Aigars Nords)

Blind Tasting vs. ROBERT PARKER - who finds the 100 POINT WINE?!
▶︎

Blind Tasting vs. ROBERT PARKER - who finds the 100 POINT WINE?!

Tor Kenward's Good Life: The Making of a Napa Wine Legend
▶︎

Tor Kenward's Good Life: The Making of a Napa Wine Legend

IRAN: THIS IS THE LAST WARNING - w/ Col. Macgregor, Dimitri Lascaris, Aaron, Karim & Scott Horton
▶︎

IRAN: THIS IS THE LAST WARNING - w/ Col. Macgregor, Dimitri Lascaris, Aaron, Karim & Scott Horton

"Yo abro un Romanée-Conti": la botella de vino de 10.000 euros con la que sueña Santi Rivas
▶︎

"Yo abro un Romanée-Conti": la botella de vino de 10.000 euros con la que sueña Santi Rivas

Willy Pérez: Past, Present, and Future of Sherry Wine | The Wine Bunker #13
▶︎

Willy Pérez: Past, Present, and Future of Sherry Wine | The Wine Bunker #13