«УЧИЛКА» Татьяна Гартман — РАЗГРОМНАЯ КРИТИКА ОТ ЛИНГВИСТА. Обличение дилетантизма и лжеграмотности

Support the channel with a donation! • For viewers from Russia — https://boosty.to/mikitkosynalexeev • For viewers outside Russia —   / mikitkosynalexeev   Abstract: Nizhny Novgorod teacher Tatyana Gartman, creator of the channel "Uchilka vs TV," is currently at the height of her fame: she's been invited to work at Mayak Radio, she's been offered a job teaching government officials, she regularly appears on television, the media writes about her, and she's promoted by top bloggers with millions of followers. But is she worthy of all this attention? She, who constantly makes factual errors, promotes some outdated taste and amateurism, demonstrates double standards, and doesn't skimp on empty accusations! Is it really true that there's no more worthy expert on Russian language in our country? In the six years I've been running the channel, I've never reviewed other bloggers. I never even thought I'd ever do this. But for a year now, I've seen "Uchilka" gain popularity, and everyone admires it—even though it needs the harshest criticism! Prescriptivism—fight! In turn, I'll say that the purpose of the video is not to offend Tatyana (even though she once insulted my channel out of nowhere), but to publicly criticize her work and draw public attention to current issues in linguistics. I'd be a hundred times happier if Tatyana responded to my criticism and admitted her MISTAKES—something she constantly encourages people to do herself. UPDATE: A response has been received. See the comment —    • «УЧИЛКА» Татьяна Гартман — РАЗГРОМНАЯ КРИТ...   Contents: 00:00 Introduction 02:54 Tatyana's Mistakes and Misstatements 02:54 Zero and Zero 03:29 To accustom and to accustom 03:54 In several hundred words 05:15 Different linguistic schools: doshch' (rain) and dozhd' (rain) 06:17 To eat 07:01 To come and to come 08:55 The letter Ё in words with the root "zhen-" 11:13 To fasten and to fasten 12:43 To dive and to dive 13:18 What content would I recommend Tatyana make? 14:06 "Mistakes" that Tatyana criticizes others for, but which she makes in her own speech. And how she explains them differently in herself and others. 16:40 Tatyana accuses others of being uninsightful, but she herself fails to notice the obvious. Analysis of the case with my video. 19:09 Tatyana's low level of theoretical knowledge of language 20:40 Analysis of the statement about the stress shift between "convicted" and "sedited" in her book 22:25 The real reasons for this change 23:50 "Speech Nuance" - my program about literary norms 25:15 Critique of the general approach. What is prescriptivism and why does it contradict the modern scientific view of language? 26:30 Concepts Tatyana speculates on: "error" and "rule," "correct"—and how this leads to a false understanding of language. 29:30 Tatyana denies people linguistic agency, and language, in her opinion, "fluctuates with the party line." 30:25 Tatyana commits forgery. 31:03 Some of Tatyana's prescriptions run counter to common sense. 33:30 The inconsistency of some prescriptions. 34:07 What the average person notices about changes in language and what they consider "illiterate." 35:56 How celebrities react to Tatyana's analyses. 37:15 Responses to some objections. 38:12 Words in defense of Tatyana. My other materials: • Playlist "Speech Nuance" —    • РЕЧЕВОЙ НЮАНС [ «Ошибки» в речи, их истори...   Videos about "Neta," "Zvonit," "Kushat," and "Ikhniy" are also here. • Conversation #3. Russian language norms—what's REALLY behind them? —    • Нормы русского языка — что за ними стоит Н...   (I warn you, there's a long, 12-minute joke at the beginning. Skip to the 12th minute immediately. That was three years ago. I was making weird, hour-and-a-half-long videos back then...) • Conversation #4. Why is Russian stress so complex? —    • Почему русское ударение такое сложное?   • OLD MOSCOW PRONUNCIATION and what's left of it —    • СТАРОМОСКОВСКОЕ ПРОИЗНОШЕНИЕ и что от него...   See See also: • Teacher's video with me —    • «Училка vs ТВ»: ОШИБКИ В ГЛАГОЛАХ!   • "Proofreader vs. Teacher" from the "S/PRAVKA" channel —    • КОРРЕКТОР VS УЧИЛКА   • Zaliznyak A. A.: An Episode from the History of Russian Stress —    • А. А. Зализняк: Эпизод из истории русского...   • Marginalist Continues to Destroy Teacher (Interview with Pushnoy) —    • Маргинал продолжает уничтожать Училку (инт...   Subscribe to our other resources! • Main Telegram — https://t.me/chtenye_tg • VK — https://vk.com/chtenye_vk • Instagram —   / mikitko_syn_alexeev   • Telegram with photos — https://t.me/mikitko_syn_alexeev • Website — https://mikitko.ru