Peygambere Niçin Gerek Var? - Altay Cem Meriç | Bildiğin Gibi Değil | B13

In this episode of the "Not As You Know It" program, prepared and presented by Altay Cem Meriç, we examine the debates surrounding: the denial of hadith, mutawatir knowledge, the relationship between the Quran and hadith, and the issue of methodology. We discuss what frequently voiced claims such as "Hadiths are unreliable," "There is no such thing as mutawatir," "Hadiths were written 200-250 years later" mean in terms of epistemology and consistency. In this episode, we address: what mutawatir knowledge is, why the Quran is considered in the same category as it, what consequences rejecting narrated knowledge altogether leads to, and why selective skepticism is a methodological problem. 📌 Topics covered in this episode: 📖 What is Mutawatir? What conditions must a piece of information meet to be considered "certain"? 📚 The Quran and Mutawatir (Radiation of Transmission): Is there really a disconnect between the way the Quran reached us and the way hadiths were transmitted? 🧠 The Problem of Selective Doubt: Is it consistent to accept Aristotle, historical events, and modern knowledge while rejecting hadiths? ⚖️ The Claim that "Hadiths are Conjectural": What does conjecture mean, is every conjecture worthless, and what does "conjectural evidence" mean in methodology? 🕰️ The Claim that "Hadiths were Written 250 Years Later": How historically accurate is this claim, and when did the compilation of hadiths actually begin? 📜 Did Bukhari Fabricate Hadiths? Or was it simply a matter of classifying narrations? 🧩 Is the Text the Problem, or the Method? Where does the real problem begin in hadith debates? 🔔 Don't miss this important conversation where knowledge, method, and consistency intersect. 👉 For other parts of the series:    • Bildiğin Gibi Değil | Altay Cem Meriç   Let's think together… #AltayCemMeriç #NotAsYouKnowIt #YCDYapı 🔔 Don't forget to subscribe to our channel: youtube.com/c/mymecra?sub_confirmation=1 👉 MyMecra's Other Playlists 👇 🔹 One Day | Serdar Tuncer:    • Biri Bir Gün | Serdar Tuncer   🔹 Our Own Sky | Ibrahim Kalın:    • Kendi Gökkubbemiz | İbrahim Kalın   🔹 Listen to the Ney | Ömer Tuğrul İnançer:    • Dinle Neyden | Ömer Tuğrul İnançer   🔹 Should I Die If I Don't Say It? | Ömer Demirbağ:    • Ya Ben Öleyim mi Söylemeyince | Ömer Demirbağ   🔹 The Pleasure of Remembrance | Sadettin Ökten:    • Zevk-i Tahattur | Sadettin Ökten   🔹 Look at It From This Perspective Too | Savaş Şafak Barkçin:    • Bi' De Buradan Bak | Savaş Şafak Barkçin   🔹 Hayati Verses | Hayati İnanç:    • Hayâtî Beyitler | Hayati İnanç   🔹 The Traveler's Notebook | Ahmet Kemal Öncü:    • Seyyahın Not Defteri | Ahmet Kemal Öncü   🔹 Actually It's Not Like That | Koray Şerbetçi & Ozan Bodur:    • Aslında Öyle Değil | Koray Şerbetçi & Ozan...   🔹 Traces:    • İzler | MyMecra   🔹 Civilization Horizon | Sadettin Ökten:    • Medeniyet Ufku | Sadettin Ökten   🔹 What is the Topic? - Uğur Işılak & Serdar Tuncer:    • Konu Nedir? | Serdar Tuncer & Uğur Işılak   🔹 Last33 | Orhan Karaağaç:    • Son33 | Orhan Karaağaç   🔹 Success Demands a Price | Nurullah Genç:    • Başarı Bedel İster | Nurullah Genç   🔹 Associations | Savaş Ş. Barkçin:    • Çağrışımlar | Savaş Şafak Barkçin   🔹 Escape Ramp | Talha Gülören:    • Kaçış Rampası | Talha Gülören   🔹 Let's Think About It | Ömer Türker:    • Bi' Düşünelim | Ömer Türker   🔹 MyMecra Short Videos:    • MyMecra Kısa Videolar   🔹 Like Me, So Strange:    • Şöyle Garip Bencileyin | MyMecra   🔹 Thought Atlas | MyMecra:    • Düşünce Atlası | MyMecra   🔹 The Peak of the Love Zodiac | MyMecra:    • Aşk Burcunun Zirvesi | MyMecra   🔹 Prescription with Saliha Erdim:    • Reçete | Saliha Erdim   🔹 Caravan of Eternity | MyMecra:    • Sonsuzluk Kervanı | MyMecra   🔹 What Does God Tell Us? | Yasin Pişgin:    • Mevla Bize Ne Söyler | Prof. Dr. Yasin Pişgin   👍 To JOIN our FAMILY 👉    / @mymecra   You can follow us on the following Social Media Addresses: 🔻 Facebook:   / mymecra   🔻 Instagram:   / mymecra   🔻 Twitter:   / mymecra   🔻 Website: http://mymecra.com/ Platforms where you ca...