האם ישראל נלחמת בצורה מוסרית? | ד"ר רונן שובל VS ד"ר משואה שגיב

"On Meaning Plus" Subscription Plan ➕: https://bit.ly/4bZqvRi Early access to episodes 🎧 Premium clips 💎 Weekly meeting 🖥️ Access to courses 🧮 Support for independent and influential media outlets 📢 In this episode of the "On Meaning" podcast, Attorney Tamir Dortal hosts Dr. Ronen Shoval and Dr. Massua Sagiv for a debate on morality, identity, and the philosophy of fighting in the shadow of the war in Gaza. Does the humanization of our enemies endanger IDF soldiers on the battlefield? In a penetrating and thorough discussion, Dr. Shoval and Dr. Sagiv present two opposing worldviews regarding Israel's moral path in the face of a cruel enemy. Dr. Sagiv argues that maintaining a human image and a commitment to universal values ​​alongside particular Jewish values ​​are an inseparable part of our strength as a society, and warns against animalization and a sense of revenge. On the other hand, Dr. Shoval sharply criticizes classical liberalism, which disconnects the individual from his context. He claims that, in the face of an enemy that operates from a radical theology and religious consciousness of a "death cult," the use of force is not only a necessity but a positive moral action designed to eradicate evil from the world. The conversation ranges from an in-depth analysis of radical Muslim culture, through the concept of the Iron Wall and deterrence for generations, to a heated debate about self-criticism in Israeli society – are internal investigations like those in the Yemenite field affair evidence of our high morality, or an expression of pathology, the evil eye, and domestic auto-anti-Semitism? In this episode, you will hear a rare philosophical-practical discussion on the seam line between security and morality, and learn how deep philosophical concepts directly influence decisions made on the battlefield and Israel's foreign policy. Is it possible to win in the Middle East with Western tools? And how do we remain a moral society without jeopardizing our existence? Join us for an enlightening listen. Merchandise 👕🏷: https://bit.ly/AlHmMerchandise Business Inquiries 💼 – Matan: 058-424-2590 List of recommended readings 📚: https://bit.ly/3rXRwvN Newsletter 📧 - http://eepurl.com/iv2c6k 00:00:00 Does humanizing the enemy endanger soldiers? 00:05:41 The Root of the Problem in Liberalism and Jewish Identity 00:10:23 The Double Obligation: The People of Israel and Universal Values 00:16:32 Loving Humanity Begins with Loving Yourself and Your Family 00:20:38 Using Force to Eradicate Evil is a Moral Action 00:24:48 Are There Innocents Inside the Gaza Strip? 00:30:15 The need for a conscious decision for generations against Hamas 00:36:00 Radical Islam and the concept of Dar al-Harb 00:46:20 The Abraham Accords and the two-state solution 00:52:53 How the Arab collective unconscious manages reality 01:03:16 The Left's mental movement: Criticism as self-flagellation 01:10:09 A dilemma in the field: an IDF soldier and the Palestinian child 01:18:20 The Yemeni field affair and the limits of internal investigation 01:25:20 The Israel Defense Forces and hypocrisy in the Western world (Premium) #Podcast #On_Meaning Studio design: Yair Karl