Debunking Professor Dave: Lee Cronin Part 01 “Experts” DEBUNKED & Prebiotic Soup

THIS is Episode 1 - The Religion of Prebiotic Soup & Extrapolations - Lee Cronin, Part 01 Ep 2:    • Debunking Professor Dave: Lee Cronin, Part...   Ep 3:    • Debunking Professor Dave: Lee Cronin, Part...   Ep 4:    • Debunking Professor Dave: Bruce Lipschutz ...   Ep 5:    • Debunking Professor Dave: Bruce Lipshutz P...   Ep 6:    • Debunking Professor Dave: Steve Benner, Pa...   Ep 7:    • Debunking Professor Dave: Steve Benner, Pa...   Ep 8:    • Debunking Professor Dave: Steve Benner, Pa...   Episode 9 premieres soon! SUBSCRIBE so you'll be notified! Dr. Tour is back! Addressing Abiogenesis, Season 2 is here! In this first episode, after looking back to how the prebiotic soup model is being taught in scientific textbooks, we review an interview between Lee Cronin and Dr. James Tour that referenced a previous interview between Lee Cronin and Justin Brierley. In those interviews, Cronin explained his research—an algorithmic search for life—and how the search is for a semantically different type of "life"—a molecular system reduced to one that can move towards replicating itself and one that can be created randomly in a lab. Given the requirements for life as we know it today, even crude requirements for the simplest life, involve much more than Cronin's reduced definition, Dr. Tour questioned Cronin for a clarification to a statement he made to Brierley where Cronin affirmed that life arose as a result of chemical reactions in a prebiotic soup. Dr. Tour asked Cronin for evidence of such an extrapolated claim, and he reminded Cronin that, even if evidence of life exists in the fossil record, such evidence doesn't explain the “how”. How simple molecules transitioned from non-living matter into living matter—Dr. Tour reminds us that scientists are clueless on that. When ultimately pinned down on the question, Cronin agreed that we don’t know. Don't forget to like, subscribe, and share! ==== Support us in creating more content across our different media platforms. Visit https://jesusandscience.org/#Support to learn more. ==== Check out all our episodes: Addressing Abiogenesis, Season 2    • Addressing Abiogenesis:  Season 02   Addressing Abiogenesis, Season 1    • Addressing Abiogenesis: Season 1   VIDEO INDEX 00:00 Once There Was A Chemist 01:09 Intro 01:58 A New Series on Abiogenesis 03:13 Dear Jim 04:36 The Hype around OOL 05:50 Three Chemists Walk Into A Bar 11:12 Science Communicator 13:08 Primordial Soup 15:04 Lee Cronin 16:55 Let Cronin Speak 21:31 Salad Dressing 25:01 How Did Life Come From Primordial Soup? 25:53 Give Me The Evidence 30:52 See You Next Time! #abiogenesis #originoflife #evolution Papers Addressed in Cronin Series: Spontaneous formation of autocatalytic sets with self-replicating inorganic metal oxide clusters; https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073... Autocatalysis: Kinetics, Mechanisms and Design; https://chemistry-europe.onlinelibrar... Taming the Combinatorial Explosion of the Formose Reaction via Recursion within Mineral Environments; https://chemistry-europe.onlinelibrar... Formation of oligopeptides in high yield under simple programmable conditions; https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomm... Amino Acid Structures; https://www.neb.com/tools-and-resourc... Autonomous model protocell division driven by molecular replication; https://www.nature.com/articles/s4146... God bless. ~ https://jesusandscience.org Dr Tour's Personal Website - http://jmtour.com Twitter -   / drjamestour   Facebook -   / drjamestour   LinkedIn -   / drjamestour   Instagram -   / drjamestour   Snapchat -   / drjamestour   WeChat - @drjamestour