Interrogation of Destiny Madrid | Oct. 11, 2011 | Johnny Clarke & Lisa Straub murder investigation

Based on a conversation between Tiffany Williams and Johnny Clarke, police believe that Clarke and his girlfriend Lisa Straub were attacked at 10:41 p.m. A call between Sam Williams and Destiny Madrid at 10:27 p.m. pinged off a cell phone tower near the Bottom Line Bar. It was at that point that Williams says he was calling Madrid to see when she would get to the bar. In an Oct. 11, 2011, interview with detectives, Madrid repeatedly tells police that she was with Sam that night and that they later went to the Bedford Inn. At one point, retired Toledo Detective Tom Ross, who was working for the prosecutor's office shushes her. At another point in the interview, Detective Jeff Kozak tells her that she is not on bar's video. She appears stunned and says, "we have to be. We were right by the front door." In his interview with Williams' cousin Larry Gillhouse, who was also at the Bottom Line bar, Kozak acknowledges that he had no video from the bar, that he was told by the bar owner that there was none from that night. Gillhouse tells Kozak that he didn't remember hanging out that night after the birthday party, but he says he remembers hanging out at a different time for someone's 21st birthday. But that was likely a mutual acquaintance, Nikk's, birthday on Jan. 31. Williams says that the group stayed at Bottom Line until after 1, then went to a different bar for last call. He said that he and Gillhouse were briefly separated. But he said he called him to figure out where they could go for an early morning meal. Phone records show he called Gillhouse at 2:51 a.m., 3:01 and 3:04 for a total of nearly five minutes. He also placed six calls to Cameo Pettaway between 2:38 and 3:27 a.m. Prosecutors claim that this was more evidence that the men were involved in the crime and Sam was calling to solidify their story. The calls were unanswered. Williams explains that he was cheating on his current girlfriend with Madrid and trusted Pettaway to be discreet. "I was looking for a place to have relations with this woman. I was looking for a place, other than a hotel, to go," Williams says. "I knew that he would not tell." Williams says that there are texts and Facebook posts that would prove his story. 11 Investigates has tried multiple times to have Facebook provide the posts but has not been successful. The police have not returned two phones of Williams', though his family has made multiple attempts to get them back. Police did receive a court order to obtain his text messages, but there has been no explanation why they were not used in the trial. MORE: https://www.wtol.com/article/news/inv... Subscribe to WTOL11: https://bit.ly/32odAkM​ Connect with us on social media: Go 419 Facebook -   / ​   Facebook -   / ​   Twitter:   / ​   Instagram -   / ​   WTOL 11 newsletter - https://wtol.com/email